Welcome to our new website!
Nov. 21, 2026

Is Late Night Dead - 3. Late Night with Conan O'Brien - The Guy Nobody Wanted

Is Late Night Dead - 3. Late Night with Conan O'Brien - The Guy Nobody Wanted
Is Late Night Dead - 3. Late Night with Conan O'Brien - The Guy Nobody Wanted
Daily Comedy News: a podcast about comedians
Is Late Night Dead - 3. Late Night with Conan O'Brien - The Guy Nobody Wanted

An unknown writer from The Simpsons takes over David Letterman’s old job in 1993. The critics hate him, and NBC nearly fires him. Then.... the show starts to work...and Conan eventually gets The Tonight Show.

Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/daily-comedy-news-with-johnny-mac--4522158/support.

🎄 DCN every day, no ads, for the whole family: Caloroga+ on Apple Podcasts is $49.99 a year and shares with up to 6 people. Try it free for 30 days: tap Try Free in Apple Podcasts.

Today's DCN is brought to you by MyBookie use promo code DCN!

Daily Comedy News is hosted by Johnny Mac and releases every weekday. Subscribe on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, or your favorite app. Part of the Caloroga Media network. For transcripts and show notes visit www.dailycomedynews.com

Daily Comedy News with Johnny Mac is a daily podcast covering comedians, stand-up comedy, late night television, and the comedy industry. New episodes every morning. Follow on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you listen.

Contact John at John@thesharkdeck dot com

For Uninterrupted Listening, use the Apple Podcast App and click the banner that says Uninterrupted Listening. $4.99/month

John's Substack about media is free.

0:03 Hi, I'm. Johnny Mac, and Late Night with Conan O'Brien is somebody else's 1230. I've said my piece about my 1230, Late Night with David Letterman. I like Conan, but for the same reasons I didn't watch David 1130, a guy in New York City in his mid-20s, I didn't watch much of Conan. Sure, I saw the clips. Sure, I've come to love Conan. Sure, I appreciate that what Conan did was both in the spirit of Letterman without copying Dave at all, but I wasn't like sitting there every night at 1230 going, this is the guy. In the spring of 1994... Conan O'Brien was the host of a network talk show, and reportedly some nights they couldn't fill the audience.

0:50 It was Studio 6A at 30 Rock. That was the same room David Letterman had spent 11 years turning 1230 into the coolest hour of television and a room I had been in several times. The network wasn't giving Conan real contracts. He was renewed 13 weeks at a time and once for only six weeks. Executives were openly talking about replacing him, and the name everybody was passing around was Greg Kinnear. Robert Smigel, Conan's head writer, later said, We were basically canceled. Hi, I'm Johnny Mac, and this is Is Late Night Dead? The last two weeks were about David Letterman, the guy who made 1230 matter. This is about the guy who inherited 1230, nearly got thrown out of it, and ended up as the truest heir Dave ever had. If David Letterman is the North Star of this series, Conan O'Brien is the closest thing David Letterman had to a spiritual successor. And the funny part is nobody saw that coming in 1993, and I don't think Conan did either. Let's start with the job openings.

1:40 In January of 1993, David Letterman announced he was going to CBS. That left NBC with a 12.35 time slot, a very profitable show worth of advertisers, and nobody to host it. NBC made it Lorne Michaels' problem. Lorne started auditioning comedians. Jon Stewart was reportedly in the mix. So was Drew Carey. Dina Carvey was approached and said no. Gary Shaling, who did a good job filling in on The Tonight Show many times before Jay Leno got the permanent slot as the fill-in, Gary Shanling was approached and said no. Greg Kinnear was hosting Talk Soup on E! and kind of looks like what a network would think a talk show host should look like. Not a big gangly guy with a shocker red hair. Greg Kinnear was like movie star looks and he was expected to get the show. But meanwhile, Lorne had a different idea. A guy named Conan O'Brien. Lorne knew him as a writer on Saturday Night Live. and Lorne wanted Conan to produce the new show. Conan's agent kept telling everyone Conan doesn't want to produce it, he wants to host it, which sounded insane because Conan had never hosted anything, had barely been on camera. He was a writer, a very good one.

2:40 He grew up in Brookline, Massachusetts, went to Harvard, became president of the Harvard Lampoon. He wrote for HBO's Not Necessarily the News. In January of 1988, Lorne hired him at Saturday Night Live. Conan left in 1991, burned out, and later said, I had no plan whatsoever. He and Robert Smigel wrote a pilot for NBC called Look Well with Adam West. Remember, Batman, as a washed-up TV detective, it aired once in 1991, did not get picked up, but became a cult favorite anyway. You know, I recognize you. Aren't you Ty Lookwell? Yes. But until this audition's over, I prefer to be addressed as Buzz McCool. Well, it's nice to meet you. You know, I remember Banachek. That was a great show. No, I wasn't Banachek. That was George Pappard. I was Banigan. Branigan? No, that was Hugh O'Brien.

3:25 I was Bannigan. Oh, right, right. You had the Black Secretary. No, that was Mannix. I had a sheepdog. Then Conan O'Brien went to The Simpsons, where he wrote what I will argue is the greatest of all The Simpsons episodes, Marge vs. the Monorail. You know, a town with money is a little like the mule with a spinning wheel. No one knows how he got it, and dang if he knows how to use it. Mule. The name's Landley. Lyle Landley. And I come before you good people tonight with an idea. Probably the greatest... Oh, it's not for you. It's more of a Shelbyville idea. Now, wait just a minute. We're twice as smart as the people of Shelbyville. Just tell us your idea and we'll vote for it.

4:08 All right. I tell you what I'll do. I'll show you my idea. I give you the Springfield Monorail. I've sold monorails to Brockway, Ogdenville, and North Haverbrook. And by gummit, put them on the map. Well, sir, there's nothing on Earth like a genuine, bona fide, electrified six-car monorail. What'd I say? Monorail. What's it called? Monorail. That's right, monorail. Monorail. Anyway, Lorne Michaels let him audition. On April 13, 1993, Conan did a test show on the set of The Tonight Show with Jay Leto, of all places. Jason Alexander and Mimi Rogers were his guests or fake guests. I mean, they were there. They were actually there, but there was no actual show. Thank you for coming.

4:50 I appreciate it. How could I miss an opportunity like this? No. The people who saw this called it awkward. That's the end of my mock show. If that's all I ever get. It was a lot of fun. I had a good time. Thank you very much. On April 26th, you know, that's 13 days later, NBC and Lorne Michaels gave him the job anyway. There was one more wrinkle. Conan was still under contract at Fox for The Simpsons and Fox wouldn't let him out for free. So NBC and Conan split the cost of buying out his contract. You got to think about that. You get the biggest break of your life and you have to pay to get out of the deal. Nobody knew who Conan O'Brien was. When he was introduced to the country that spring, the reaction was basically, who? He was a 30-year-old writer with a name nobody could pronounce. Again, when you saw it in print, you would have said Conan, as in Conan the Barbarian. You had to get used to saying Conan. He had big red hair. He was a super tall red hair. He had no on-camera experience.

5:41 And he was taking over for David Letterman. Conan picked a sidekick, a deadpan guy from Chicago named Andy Richter, who hadn't done TV either. And for a band, this was pretty cool. It got Max Weinberg, the drummer from Bruce Springsteen's E Street Band. Somehow, Late Night with Conan O'Brien premiered on September 13th, 1993, two weeks after David Letterman started his CBS show. Conan knew what you were thinking, so he opened the show saying it out loud. The cold open followed him walking through 30 Rock to the studio, and everybody he passed reminded him he had to be as good as Letterman. Conan, Tom Brokaw, I just want to be the first to welcome you to NBC. Thanks, Tom. And best of luck to you. Oh, and Conan, one more thing.

6:21 You better be as good as Letterman. Or else. The first guest was John Goodman. John was given a medal for being the first guest. Drew Barrymore was on, and so was Tony Randall. The next night, the musical guest was some band nobody in America had heard of yet. Radiohead. Who are they? Critics killed them. The Chicago Sun-Times called Conan O'Brien nervous, unprepared, and generally geeky. Tom Shales at the Washington Post, at that time the most important TV critic in the country, wrote that Conan had, quote, dark beady little eyes like a rabbit and suggested he resume his previous identity, Conan Oblivion. This is the man who later would get the Mark Twain Prize for comedy. The general consensus was that Conan O'Brien was too smart, too East Coast, too young, too tall. He was a writer pretending to be a host, and you could tell. He was stiff in the interviews. He laughed too hard at his own jokes. He rubbed his hands together, fiddled with his tie. And if you watch the early episodes now, yeah, all that's true. But here's the thing, which brings us back to the Dave era and the spiritual successor. The comedy was weird and it was smart. Robert Smigel was running the writer's room and the comedy pieces were better than anything else on network TV at that time. The problem was that Conan looked like he was going to throw up. He handled the reviews the only way he knew how, which was to make fun of them. He wrote a piece in the New York Times reviewing his own premiere under the headline, O'Brien Flops. Then, 1994, the ratings were bad, the advertisers were nervous, NBC renewed the show in 13-week chunks, at one point only six-week chunks,

7:52 interns filling the seats, Greg Kinnear talk started again, the staff went to work every day assuming this might be the last week. And then, on February 28, 1994, you know who was the guest? David Letterman. I love what you've done with the place, by the way. It's very, very nice. I chose these colors myself. It's very strange for me to be here. I was actually here a couple of, about six weeks ago. We were shooting some silly videotape outside of the building, and it was about nine o'clock in the evening, and people said, well, let's go on upstairs to the sixth floor where you used to work and take a look around. And so we came up in here, and it was just like it was now, except you folks weren't here. Well, most of you weren't here. And then we looked around, looked at the commissary, looked at the nightly news set, and then we left. And then two days later, in the newspaper was an article that we had broken in, pushed our way past the guard, and I had gone up to Brant Gumbel's office and taken a nap. What more heinous a stunt could a man pull?

8:52 I don't care who sees me. I'm sleeping on this couch, boys. Cover me. I'm taking a nap. You like it, though? You really like what we've done here? Does it look good? Yeah, it does look good. And the thing that I liked about it when I came in here, I was in this studio since 1981. We did a morning show. You did the morning show here? Right here, exactly. I didn't know that. And it was comforting to me to see that you guys have carved out a completely new identity for yourselves. And when I watched the show, it was funny. When I first watched the show, it was a little difficult for me because they say late night, and I'd think. Hey, Keen. I'll be on. Yeah. Yeah. And then it would be Conan O'Brien, late night with Conan, and I'd say to myself, and this is how stupid I am, I would say to myself, oh, geez, I wish I had a show.

9:38 David Letterman comes on. He sits on the couch and said he thought the show was good. Conan called it a morale boost and explained, I'm thinking, if the guy who created the 1230 thing comes on and says we're smart and funny, let's go. Now, it didn't fix the ratings, but the guy who had invented the anti-talk show recognized that this was a real thing as an anti-talk show. Network executives are going to network executives. NBC was still ready to pull the plug. But in August of 1994, they changed their mind. They kept Conan O'Brien. The show found itself. Conan got better at the job. He stopped trying to be a talk show host and leaned into the thing he actually was, a self-mocking nerd who'd do anything for a laugh. The interviews loosened up. People even younger than me started watching at 1230. But much like how I talk about 1230 and Chris Elliott, it's the bits that make the show. The masturbating bear, a guy in a bear suit and a giant diaper who came out and did what the name says, and somehow it got on the air. The pimp bot, a 1950s-style robot who acted like a pimp from a blaxploitation movie. How about in the year 2000, where Conan and Andy held flashlights under their faces and made ridiculous predictions about the future?

10:46 That bit kept going after the year 2000 had come and gone. And then, of course, Triumph the Insult Comic Dog, a rubber dog puppet with a cigar voiced by Robert Smigel. Triumph was so good that sometimes he was bigger than Conan's show itself. Dave had taken 1230 apart with irony and dropped watermelons and had a guy under his seats. Conan took the same sensibility and made it weirder. Dave's comedy was cool and detached. Conan's was ridiculous and committed. Had no shame. Wasn't trying to be cool. Was willing to do something stupid for three minutes if it made you laugh. Conan didn't copy Dave. He took the idea that 1230 was a place to experiment, and he kept experimenting for 16 years. By 1996, Late Night with Conan O'Brien was a genuine success. Tom Shales, the same guy with the Conan Oblivion line, wrote a piece called, quote, The Late Night Dawning of Conan. Conan looks back in those days when NBC was making a lot of money off the show. The network paid for the writers' meals, telling them to order anything they liked. Conan recently, at a Bloomberg conference, said the writers acted like a-holes, took that at face value, and ordered lobster and champagne. He told that story to make a part about how much Late Night has changed since, and we will come back to that because the premise of this whole series is asking the question, is Late Night dead? But in the late 90s, it was not. The show that nobody wanted was a money machine for NBC. There were changes along the way. In May of 2000, Andy Richter left to go try acting and left on good terms. The show adjusted.

12:14 Max Weinberg got pushed into the spotlight as Conan's new foil. A lot of the comedy came from how awkward Max was on camera. During the writer's strike in 2007 and 2008, Conan had no writers, so he pulled a lever on his desk that played a random clip from Walker, Texas Ranger over and over. When Mike Huckabee started rising in the polls while Chuck Norris was endorsing him, Conan took credit for it. By the end of the decade, Conan wasn't the kid who looked like he was going to throw up. He was a confident, very funny host, and he knew it. In March of 2004, NBC re-signed Jay Leno to host The Tonight Show for five more years through 2009. Conan had been at 1230 for more than a decade. His contract was coming up. Other networks were circling. There was talk of Conan going to Fox, I remember.

12:54 NBC didn't want to lose him the way they lost Dave, so... On September 27, 2004, NBC signed Conan O'Brien to a deal that promised him The Tonight Show starting in 2009. That was five years into the future. What could go wrong? Jay would keep The Tonight Show for five more years, and then Jay Leno would gracefully hand the show over to Conan, and then Conan will host The Tonight Show for, what, 25 years, something like that? Yep. It was one problem. Nobody asked Jay Leno what he wanted to do in 2009. On February 20th, 2009, Conan O'Brien did his last late night. More than three million people watched. Andy Richter came back for two segments. Conan packed up and moved to Los Angeles to The Tonight Show in the shadow of Johnny Corson and Jay Leno. The desk David Letterman never got.

13:39 Conan had done everything right, and he got the job without having to fight anybody over it, and he would keep it for seven months. That's next week. I'm Johnny Mack. Thanks for staying up with me. We're going on to this next gig. And sometimes I read that it's time for Conan to grow up because he's going to 1130. And I assure you, that's just not going to happen. I can't. This is who I am, for better or worse. And, yeah, it's Just, I don't know how.