Welcome to our new website!
Nov. 22, 2026

Is Late Night Dead - 4. Conan O'Brien and The Tonight Show War

Is Late Night Dead - 4. Conan O'Brien and The Tonight Show War
Daily Comedy News: a podcast about comedians
Is Late Night Dead - 4. Conan O'Brien and The Tonight Show War

Seven months as host of the Tonight Show, a primetime experiment that backfired, and the most public fight in late-night history. Then TBS, a podcast, and the Oscars.

Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/daily-comedy-news-with-johnny-mac--4522158/support.

🎄 DCN every day, no ads, for the whole family: Caloroga+ on Apple Podcasts is $49.99 a year and shares with up to 6 people. Try it free for 30 days: tap Try Free in Apple Podcasts.

Today's DCN is brought to you by MyBookie use promo code DCN!

Daily Comedy News is hosted by Johnny Mac and releases every weekday. Subscribe on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, or your favorite app. Part of the Caloroga Media network. For transcripts and show notes visit www.dailycomedynews.com

Daily Comedy News with Johnny Mac is a daily podcast covering comedians, stand-up comedy, late night television, and the comedy industry. New episodes every morning. Follow on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you listen.

Contact John at John@thesharkdeck dot com

For Uninterrupted Listening, use the Apple Podcast App and click the banner that says Uninterrupted Listening. $4.99/month

John's Substack about media is free.

0:03 On January 12, 2010, in the middle of the day, Conan O'Brien put out a statement that started with the words, People of Earth. He was the host of The Tonight Show. He'd had the job for seven months, the job Johnny Carson had for 30 years. David Letterman never got, and NBC had just told him, They were moving the show to five minutes after midnight so they could put Jay Leno back on at 1135. That's right. The Tonight Show would start at 1205 a.m. Eastern. Conan's answer was a letter to the public. And the key line was this. The Tonight Show at 1205 simply isn't the Tonight Show. Conan said he could not participate in what he honestly believed would be the show's destruction.

0:46 A talk show host was walking away from the biggest job in comedy. Rather than watch it get moved half an hour later, and he was saying so in public about his own network while still on the payroll. Hello, I'm Johnny Mac, and this is Is Late Night Dead? Last week, Conan was the kid nobody wanted at 1230 who turned into the best thing on late night TV. In 2004, NBC promised him The Tonight Show five years in advance. You know, 2009, that'll never come. They were trying to keep him from leaving. This is what happened when the network tried to keep that promise and keep Jay Leno at the same time and what Conan did after it all blew up. Next week, we'll give Jay Leno a fair hearing, but this week we're with Conan because in this story, he's the one who lost. Let's go back to that 2004 deal. NBC promised Conan The Tonight Show starting in 2009, and the plan was that Jay would hand it over and ride in the sunset.

1:35 The problem was Jay didn't want to ride off anywhere. He was still number one at 1130. And as the deadline got closer, it was clear if NBC let him walk, ABC or Fox or somebody would sign him in a heartbeat and put him up against Conan. So NBC came up with an idea that nobody in the history of TV had tried. Conan would get The Tonight Show as promised, and Jay would get a new talk show five nights a week at 10 o'clock in prime time. At the time, NBC executives called it a bold move. It was also cheap because a talk show cost a fraction of what a drama cost, and NBC was in fourth place and looking to save money anywhere it could. The risk? Well, 10 o'clock is the hour before the local news. If people didn't watch Jay Leno at 10, they wouldn't stick around at 11, and then the local stations would get hurt.

2:16 And if the local news was weak, then the lead-in for The Tonight Show would be weak. NBC went ahead anyway. Conan's Tonight Show premiered June 1, 2009, from a brand-new studio on the Universal lot in Los Angeles, and more than 9 million people watched. Well, late night doesn't touch that kind of number now. He opened by running across the country from New York to L.A., which is a very Conan way to change coasts. Andy Richter was back. Conan brought the late-night writers and the late-night sensibility with him, and he tried to bring 1230 comedy to 1135, and that's where the trouble started. In just about 20 minutes from now, Conan O'Brien will become the fifth host of The Tonight Show. Conan's taping his show on the newly refurbished Stage 1 at Universal Studios in Hollywood. After spending three months off the airwaves, Conan should be rested and raring to go.

3:00 Build set. Write jokes. Get dressed. Brush teeth. Check. Move to L.A. Move to L.A. The Tonight Show audience was older. They'd been watching Jay Leno for 17 years and Johnny for 30 before that. A lot of them didn't get Conan and they didn't want to. Within a week of the premiere, David Letterman's establishment show at CBS beat Conan in the ratings for the first time. By the fall, Conan's audience was down about 2 million people from the numbers Jay Leno had a year earlier. There were still great moments. This is the Tonight Show that gave us Norm MacDonald's moth joke.

3:42 Norm MacDonald came out with nothing prepared for a segment, and he stretched a 20-second joke he'd heard from Colin Quinn into a long story about a depressed moth visiting a podiatrist while Conan laughed and the audience cheered. We did a whole episode on Norm MacDonald on the Daily Comedy News podcast recently, so if you want to check that out, it's there. It is a perfect Conan moment, a very long, very strange piece of comedy, one of the biggest stages in comedy that a lot of people watching at 11.35 had no idea what to do with. Then on September 14th, The Jay Leno Show premiered. The guests, Jerry Seinfeld and Kanye West. 17 million people watched. Imagine if you could get 17 million people these days. Then the show collapsed by the middle of October. Local news ratings on NBC stations were falling everywhere by an average of about a quarter nationwide and as much as half in some markets. The local affiliates were losing money on the newscast. They tried to tell NBC. NBC's own station in Boston, which is Jay's hotel, by the way, had tried to refuse the show before it even premiered. NBC had a strong arm the Boston NBC affiliate into carrying Jay Leno. So in January of 2010, NBC came up with an idea. Jay would go back to 1135 for half an hour, mostly the monologue. And then the Tonight Show with Conan would start at 12.05. That way, NBC kept both of them and fixed the 10 o'clock problem.

4:59 And that's when Conan wrote the People of Earth letter. He'd said he'd been led to believe he'd get the Tonight Show for years and that pushing it back past midnight would destroy a franchise that had been on at 11.30 since Johnny Carson, and he was not going to do it. What followed was a pretty public fight in late-night history, and there's been a lot of them. NBC executives went to warn the press. Jeff Zucker, head of NBCUniversal, called the idea of painting Conan off to keep Leno outrageous... and reportedly told Conan's people, I can pay him or play him. I can ice you guys. Dick Ebersole, who ran NBC Sports, called Conan's situation an astounding failure and called the people criticizing Jay chicken-hearted and gutless. Meanwhile. Every other late-night host went after Leno. Jimmy Kimmel opened a show doing a parody of Jay and then went on Jay's own show and told him, Conan and I have children. All you have to do is take care of his cars. What's the best prank.

5:46 You ever pulled? I think the best prank I ever pulled was I told a guy that five years from now, I'm going to give you my show. And then when the five years came, I gave it to him, and then I took it back almost instantly. Wow. David Letterman, who'd been through this scenario 17 years earlier at the time of his life, he said, we went through our own version of this 17, 18 years ago and asked the audience, who's blamed Conan? Every day I wake up and I say, I'm going to keep my mouth shut about this NBC Tonight Show thing because, honestly, folks, I don't have a dog in this fight. But here's the deal. I've known Jay Leno for, I don't know, 35 years, a long, long time. And we used to buddy around in the old days. And what we're seeing now is kind of vintage Jay. And it's enjoyable for me to see this. It's like, hey, there he is. There's the guy I know. And I just thought, well, I better keep my mouth shut because, you know, Lord knows I got my own problems. Really, I got my own problems. But I just can't help myself.

6:51 And. And while it's true I don't specifically have a dog in this fight, I think that in some way I and Paul are responsible for the mess that's taking place over there now. We're responsible. Yes, because of the big stink that we created when we left NBC years and years ago, they said, okay, well, that'll never happen again. Right. Well, that's why Jay says he was going to retire five years ago just to avoid that. That's right. They wanted to avoid another transitional brouhaha. If I can invoke a little French. Please do, at any time.

7:34 So last night, Jay gave his State of the Network speech. He did. State of the Network. State of the Network. State of the Network. And he said that we should not blame Conan for what's going on. Don't blame Conan. Don't blame Conan for what's going on. And I said to myself, no one is blaming Conan. And then the fans showed up. An artist named Mike Mitchell made a poster in the style of the Obama Hope poster with Conan's face and the words, I'm with Coco. Orange became the fan's color for Conan's hair. People had rallies in L.A. and other cities and on college campuses.

8:17 For a few weeks, a fight over who got to tell jokes at 1135 was a national news story. And the network was the bad guy. On January 21st, NBC and Conan announced a settlement. Conan and his staff got about $ 45 million, roughly $ 33 million for Conan and about $ 12 million for the staff, whose jobs were about to disappear. In return, Conan would leave The Tonight Show, and he couldn't appear on television until September. The last Tonight Show with Conan O'Brien aired January 22, 2010. Tom Hanks, Steve Carell, Neil Young, Will Ferrell came out dressed as Ronnie Van Zandt from Lynyrd Skynyrd, playing a cowbell for Freebird. With a band that included Beck, Billy Gibbons from ZZ Top, and Ben Harper with Conan O'Brien playing guitar, 10 million people watched. But the moment everybody remembers is the speech.

9:04 Ladies and gentlemen, before we bring this rodeo to a close, I think a couple of things should be said. There's been a lot of speculation in the press about what I legally can and can't say about NBC. And this isn't a joke. To set the record straight, and this is true, tonight I'm allowed to say anything I want. And no, it's not a joke, but thanks, sir. Tonight I really am allowed to say whatever I want, and what I want to say is this. Between my time at Saturday Night Live, the late night show, and my brief run here on the Tonight Show, I've worked with NBC for over 20 years. Yes, we have our differences right now.

9:46 Yes, we're going our separate ways. But this company has been my home for most of my adult life. I am enormously proud of the work we've done together, and I want to thank NBC for making it all possible. I really do. A lot of people have been asking me about my state of mind, and I'll be honest with you, walking away from The Tonight Show is the hardest thing I have ever had to do. Making this choice has been enormously difficult. This is the best job in the world. I absolutely love doing it. And I have the best staff and crew in the history of the medium. I will fight anybody who says I don't, but no one would.

10:35 But despite this sense of loss, I really feel this should be a happy moment. Every comedian, every comedian dreams of hosting a Tonight Show. And for seven months, I got to do it. And I did it my way with people I love. I do not regret one second of anything that we've done here. And finally, I have something to say to our fans. This massive outpouring of support and passion from so many people has been overwhelming for me. The rallies, the signs, all this goofy, outrageous creativity on the internet. The fact that people have traveled long distances and camped out all night in the pouring rain.

11:27 It's pouring. It's been pouring for days. And they're camping out to be in. Our audience. Really, you. Here's what all of you have done. You made a sad situation joyous and inspirational. So to all the people watching, I can never, ever thank you enough for the kindness to me. I'll think about it for the rest of my life. And all I ask is one thing, and I'm asking this particularly of young people that watch. Please do not be cynical. I hate cynicism. For the record, it's my least favorite quality.

12:08 It doesn't lead anywhere. Nobody in life gets exactly what they thought they were going to get. But if you work really hard and you're kind, amazing things will happen. I'm telling you, amazing things will happen. I'm telling you, it's just true. This is the guy who just lost the job in a big public manner and he went out telling kids not to be bitter about it. Jay Leno came back as host of The Tonight Show March 1st, 2010. and 6.6 million people watched. We'll talk about that next week. For 60 years, Late Night had been about the network and the desk. The network owned the show, the time slot, and the name, and the host was a guy it hired. What the Conan War showed is that it wasn't true anymore. Sure, the network won, they had the contract, they had the time slot, they put Jay back, but the audience went with Conan. That was the first real sign of what this series was about. The desk still mattered to NBC...

12:58 But the people watching cared about the guy. So what did Conan do with no show? Under the settlement, he couldn't be on TV until September 1st. So in the spring of 2010, and I can't believe it's that long ago. This feels like five minutes ago to me. In 2010, Conan went on the road with a live comedy and music show called The Legally Prohibited From Being Funny on Television Tour, which sold out all over the country. Conan also joined Twitter. He was really good at it. On the first day of the tour, he announced a deal with TBS, a cable network known for running reruns, maybe in Atlanta Braves games if you're a little older. People thought he was crazy. He'd been the host of The Tonight Show, and now he was going to TBS. Thank you, and welcome to my second annual first show. I know what you guys are thinking. Hey, it's the guy from Twitter.

13:44 That's what you're thinking right now. Wait, you mean you're Kanye West? Shut up! I'm excited to be here and welcome to my new show. It's called Conan. This show is called Conan. People ask me why I named the show Conan. I did it so it'd be harder to replace. He's out. Get another Conan. This is an exciting night. I'm really glad to be on cable. I have to tell you that right now. That's not a joke.

14:33 Truth is. Probably doesn't help that I say that's not a joke after this. Conan premiered on TBS on November 8th, 2010 at 11 o'clock. Once again, Andy Richter at his side as sidekick and announcer. And that TBS show lasted 11 years. That's like that's a pretty long run now that I think about it. He had a smaller audience, but more freedom. The best things he did weren't even talk show segments. Starting in 2015, he went to Cuba, then Armenia, Korea, Haiti, Mexico and others for travel specials called Conan Without Borders. That won an Emmy. The ratings kept going down. To be honest, by the final season, the show was averaging fewer than 300,000 viewers. In November of 2020, Conan announced, that's it. And the last episode of Conan aired on June 24th, 2021. Jack Black, your final guest.

15:21 I'll just close with this one thought. I have devoted all of my adult life, all of it, to pursuing this strange phantom intersection between smart and stupid. And there's a lot of people that believe the two cannot coexist. But God, I will tell you, it is something that I believe religiously. I think when smart and stupid come together, it's very difficult. But if you can make it happen, I think it's the most beautiful thing in the world. I am so grateful to all my staff and the fans in this country and around the world who have joined me in this really crazy and seemingly pointless pursuit. to do things that are kind of stupid, but have something smart in there somewhere. And then there's a little tiny sort of flicker of what is a kind of a magic. I think that's what I believe. So my advice to anyone watching right now, and it's not easy to do. It is not easy to do. It's not easy to do, but try. Try and do what you love with people you love. And if you can manage that, it's the definition of heaven on earth. I swear to God, it really is.

16:26 So good night. Thank you very much. Conan told an audience at a Bloomberg conference, in this true spirit of Irish tradition, I wanted to leave the party before I was asked to leave. So that's it. We'll never hear from Conan O'Brien again. Whatever happened to that guy? He'll probably wind up doing a podcast. Yeah, he launched Conan O'Brien Needs a Friend. No band, no audience, no five-minute interview with a guest. It was just Conan being funny for an hour with people he liked. By March of 2024, it had been downloaded more than 400 million times. Conan wound up selling the Team Coco digital company for $ 150 million. He got a travel show on Max called Conan O'Brien Must Go, where he visits fans he's met through the podcast. In March of 2025, Conan O'Brien received the Mark Twain Prize for American Humor at the Kennedy Center, and he hosted the Academy Awards. He did so well that they brought him back to host again.

17:17 The guy who went from being too weird for The Tonight Show basically became the face of the entertainment industry. Recently, Conan was at the Bloomberg conference and he was asked if he believed the networks when they say late night was a bad business. He didn't say yes or no, but he said over his 17 years at NBC, he watched it change. Every war has a winner. And in this war, Jay Leno won. Or did he? Who's the one that's beloved by the people? Who's the one who has the reputation that comes with a little bit of that guy around it? Jay Leno beat David Letterman for the job in 1992 and beat Conan for the job again in 2010. He was the host of The Tonight Show for 22 years. Everybody in comedy seems to have an opinion about Jay Leno, and most of them aren't nice.

18:01 I'm going to make a case for Jay Leno next week on Is Late Night Ted? I'm Johnny Mac, and thanks for staying up with me.